I tweeted about this a little earlier, but it’s continued to bug me, so here’s a slightly more explicit breakdown of my thoughts on how CBJ are running their ‘Hockey for Her’ promo/events.
Like I said on twitter, I’ve been paying attention to the NHL closely for over a decade now, and in this time, there has been virtually no improvement whatsoever on how the NHL markets itself to female fans, or in fact to anyone who falls outside that binary or is non-gender conforming in any way.
It’s incredibly frustrating to have been here all along and still have to hear the play by play on Ballysports and on CBJ radio cheerfully spout a script that just talks about how it will “focus on educating our female fans” – I would say that I can’t believe that no one in PR or marketing or even the TV/radio crew stopped to notice how that sounds, with the implication that women don’t know anything about hockey, but I suspect the more depressing truth is that anyone who would pick up on that isn’t in a position with the power to change it.
It shouldn’t be difficult to come up with a way to make this more inviting – this tweet from Halle is a far less grating and much more interesting way to position the event, and one that I prefer enormously. The breakdown on the five different events involved on the Blue Jackets website looks a lot more promising about what it actually entails, but none of that shows in the way that it’s being presented in-game.
To quote my friend Lily, who I think absolutely nailed this: “[it comes across as if] they can’t decide who these are for. Do they want women who have never attended a hockey game? Do they want women who have been to a couple Jackets games and not more? Do they want women who watch the Jackets religiously on TV but don’t attend? Those are three separate groups they could sell more tickets to, who each have different reasons why they aren’t buying more tickets now, and you need different types of events for each.”
(And also, as Lily observed, and as has frankly been a near-universally expressed comment from the women on my feed: something about the way the TV zooms in on random women in the crowd while they’re talking about this event feels very uncomfortable and a little othering.)
Another off-putting aspect about this kind of event is that even if the whole pitch is less stereotyped and patronizing, it’s still not as welcoming as it could be.
I’m incredibly sympathetic to people wanting to both experience (and to offer!) a less sports-bro-y way of either finding like-minded people to pal up with (which would be a great angle to promote events like this from!) or to simply learn more about the game generally, or to learn more about the team specifically. I do think there’s a lot of good you can do on those fronts with very little extra effort.
But – and this is the part that so so many teams (not just CBJ) seem to miss: branding it specifically as “for her” sets up two immediate issues. Firstly, thanks for confirming you don’t think that “she” is part of the existing audience, part of the “we” who hear the ad as fans. And most emphatically: by making it such an explicitly gendered event, it only siloes hockey fandom even more than it already is.
Making it “for her” immediately excludes anyone who doesn’t pass as female or who is visibly gender non-conforming; it gives non-binary fans absolutely no recognition or space; and it makes any number of fans wonder if they’d be accepted at the event or potentially (and upsettingly!) questioned on their right to be there.
If hockey is for everyone, it needs to make a consistent, concerted effort to not just say they welcome everyone but to act like that’s the case.
And sometimes, frankly, that’s going to mean they have to stand up and say what they won’t accept, because it makes marginalised fans unwelcome. A stronger stand against sexism, homophobia, transphobia and racism—as well as more work to make games accessible to disabled audiences as well as non-traditional ones—would all do so much to emphasise that the organisations actually care about giving more than lip service to the idea that NHL hockey isn’t just for able-bodied straight white cis men.
It’s hard to ignore that this kind of event can often feel like window dressing for a culture which continues to make female fans in particular unwelcome in all kinds of subtle ways as well as the more overt ones.
This particular post isn’t a place where I want to go further into how incredibly exhausting and demoralising it is to watch the unending stream of reminders that so many people in the men’s hockey community don’t believe women are people, or to see how abuse, violence, and sexual assault are treated so often as minor blips in the career of some young athlete rather than taken seriously in any way, but that is absolutely a factor as well. It’s one very few teams or media properties have tried to engage with in more than the most glancing fashion, if that.
Marginalised fans have to contend with experiences that may be minor in the moment they occur, but that add up to a constant reminder that you’re seen as someone who doesn’t belong in the stands, at events and/or in the online communities where hockey fans gather.
You may have drunk men harrassing you at games. You’ll likely get talked down to and patronised by other fans, and often by some of the mainstream hockey media as well. You have to hear a lot of bigoted comments in the stands from both fans of your own team and the opposing team, and in either case it’s rare that the arena or team will take any serious action, no matter how threatening it can feel. You’ll probably get told you’re only interested because the players are hot. (Harold, some of us are lesbians. And also, who gives a fuck even if that was true? Our money still spends as well as Joe BlogsAboutIt’s does.)
You get offered incredibly stereotypical pink and/or sparkly clothing instead of getting the regular merch in a better range of fits, and god help you if you’re not thin, because most of the women’s section of the NHL shop goes from size tiny to slightly less than average, let alone the higher end of straight sizing, despite the fact that the majority of women in North America wear a 14 or higher1.
And that’s not even bringing up an issue that has been getting noticeably worse and worse over the last few years: where you try to go to a game and you aren’t even allowed to bring in a small bag.
Newsflash, since apparently the people making these policies want to pretend otherwise: most women’s clothing does not have pockets, or only has tiny ones. Many people will have meds and other items they need to travel with at all times, to say nothing of making it wildly obnoxious for any parents bringing small children who may well need other things for them, too. Want to bring tissues, meds, a spare mask, your wallet, your phone and your keys to a game? Tough luck. It makes going to games incredibly unwelcoming for families especially.
In the case of the Blue Jackets specifically, it’s also hard not to draw a line directly from all of these issues to the incredibly underwhelming efforts they’ve made in the last few years for LGBTQIA+/Pride nights; the words are mostly there but there’s very little backing them up, and nothing much going on outside of those specific events.
I know there’s a lot more that can be done to improve the fan experience and to bring more new fans to a sport that is a hell of a lot of fun, and I’m still here because I believe that’s possible. From what I can see, the Seattle Kraken have neatly avoided a lot of these issues with their developing fan base, and I’d love to see the rest of the league take some leaves out of their book on that front.
I am very aware there’s likely other issues (and solutions) that I don’t have the context or experience to pick up on, and haven’t even touched on here, but this post covers the things that are immediately apparent to me, and that have been frustrations for years now.
I would love to hear the Blue Jackets fan experience/marketing team in particular take some of these comments and concerns on board, or discuss what they are and aren’t doing with respect to these kinds of considerations. Several other teams I’ve followed (or even simply bought tickets to see as a visiting fan) regularly send out surveys to their fanbase to ask about what they think about game presentation, the arena experience, all that kind of thing, and the only ones I’ve seen from the Jackets in the last 5 years have been the ones asking for your opinions on their sponsors.
I really hope we’ll start to see better efforts in the future, but for now, I would deeply appreciate it if the people running things like this did a much more attentive job of speaking to the audience they do have and want to grow, instead of acting as if we aren’t already here.
In a lot of ways, this post can be summarised right down to this: it’s hard to accept that there’s been so little progress and it would be such an easy win to make a lot of this better for everyone. Please do.
1Admittedly, this is one thing that has improved a little over the past few years – there is now some plus size merch available, but it still by now means covers even the limited range marketed to women in the fanbase.
(Finally, many thanks to CBJ tlist for helping clarify and guide my thoughts here, and to Vavia for looking this over for me.)
